Château Laurier Addition

Night view of from Majors Hill Park. Rendering by architectsAlliance

HERITAGE OTTAWA

June 28, 2018

Forfeiting its Right of Final Approval, City Council Votes to "Return to the Drawing Board" on Château Laurier Addition

Final Approval for Design Changes to be Delegated to City Staff

City Council voted unanimously on June 27, 2018 to approve the Built Heritage Sub Committee’s (BHSC) amendment to the City Staff Report recommendation that the design of the addition to the Château Laurier hotel be approved in its proposed form. The amendment calls for staff to work with the applicants, Larco Investments and its architect Peter Clewes of architectsAlliance, and return an improved design that is more “visually compatible with the existing Château Laurier.”

Heritage Ottawa supported the intention of the BHSC initiative, but retains strong concerns that the BHSC recommendation did not go far enough to ensure that subsequent design changes will achieve design excellence while meeting the Standards and Guidelines’ test of compatibility. 

Heritage Ottawa recommended the following more robust review process be established:

  • Reconstitute the 2017 Heritage Working Group (as suggested by BHSC) to guide the proponent on subsequent design changes;
  • Re-engage the Urban Design Review Panel in a formal review of the resulting design;
  • Invite the public to an Open House before submitting the resulting design for approval, and
  • Amend Recommendation 1(e) of the BHSC Motion, and make any other necessary amendments in order that the resulting design be referred back to BHSC, Planning Committee and Ottawa City Council for final approval under auspices of the Ontario Heritage Act.

The final bullet expresses Heritage Ottawa’s firm belief that final design approval should not be delegated to city staff, as the motion recommended, but rather that Ottawa City Council should exercise its full authority and responsibility under the Ontario Heritage Act by fully considering all stages of this significant and historic application to alter the Château Laurier hotel.

Planning Committee chose to support the BHSC amendment, without additional changes, at its meeting of June 26.  At the meeting, Councillor Tobi Nussbaum (chair of BHSC) confirmed for the public record that City staff had committed to consult with the city’s Urban Design Review Panel on the resulting design changes.

Council's decision means that the approval of the final design for the Château Laurier addition ultimately rests with City staff.  With this vote, Ottawa’s elected officials have given up their right under the Ontario Heritage Act to determine whether or not the applicant has met the criteria established in the BHSC amendment. Council will not vote on the final design.

Members of BHSC and councillors will only be able to comment on the Site Plan, which will address such issues as the building’s location, landscaping and traffic and pedestrian access—not the final design of the addition.

City staff anticipate that the Site Plan will not be ready until early winter.

ABOUT THE PROCESS:

As a building designated under the Ontario Heritage Act, any addition to the Château Laurier required the approval of Ottawa City Council before construction can proceed. The owners submitted a heritage application to the City of Ottawa, as required by the Act.  Steps in the process were as follows:

  • City heritage staff issued a Report on June 11, 2018 recommending approval of the application.
  • Ottawa's Built Heritage Subcommittee (BHSC) met on June 18 to to consider the application and make recommendations to Planning Committee (PC). BHSC unanimously supported a proposed amendment to make the addition “more visually compatible with the existing Château Laurier” (see Motion above).
  • Planning Committee (PC) met on June 26, and recommended adoption of BHSC's proposed amendment to the Mayor and Ottawa City Council.
  • The Mayor and Ottawa City Council met on June 27 and voted to approve the application as amended, delegating approval for any design changes to city staff.

MORE INFORMATION:

  • Phyllis Lambert to Mayor Jim Watson: Architects of Proposed Château Laurier Addition "Have Not Found a Viable Approach"

    HERITAGE OTTAWA

    Architectural visionary Phyllis Lambert, widely considered one of the world's most influential figures in architecture, has written a letter to Mayor Jim Watson to express...

  • Coffman on Proposed Château Laurier Addition: Compatibility

    THE HTA BLOG, By Peter Coffman

    Several objections were raised at last Monday’s meeting of the Built Heritage Sub-Committee to the proposed extension of the Château Laurier. The thread that...

  • Jeanes: Château Laurier addition – design excellence must be the standard

    OTTAWA CITIZEN, By David Jeanes

    The following is offered in rebuttal to a column by Mohammed Adam (Ottawa Citizen, June 11) about the proposed addition to the Château Laurier:

    ...

  • Heritage Sub-committee wants council to send Château Laurier back to the drawing board

    OTTAWA CITIZEN, By Jon Willing

    The city’s built-heritage subcommittee is recommending the architects of the Château Laurier addition go back to the drawing board.

    The panel of...

  • Heritage committee demands more changes to Château annex

    'We want to feel the addition loves the Château as much as we do'

    CBC NEWS, By Laura Osman

    The architects behind a controversial addition to Ottawa's Château Laurier still don't have...

  • When Architecture Fails to Speak for Itself… The Château Laurier Addition

    Savanturier Blog,  By Andrew Waldron

    Imagine it is 2030 and over the past decade the Château Laurier addition has been derided not only for its misunderstanding of architecture, but for the...

  • Reevely: Latest plans for Château Laurier finally clear the lowest bar

    OTTAWA CITIZEN, By Dave Reevely

    The latest plans for an addition to the Château Laurier would have been a good starting point. They can’t be the end.

    Two years after throwing up a...

  • Council decision on Château Laurier addition will be based on rules, not feelings

    OTTAWA CITIZEN, By Jon Willing

    Ottawa city council’s decision on the controversial Château Laurier addition will come down to how the proposal stacks up against the rules, not the feelings...

  • City hall heritage experts recommend approving the controversial Château Laurier addition

    OTTAWA CITIZEN, By Jon Willing

    City heritage planners support the Château Laurier’s proposed design for its glassy seven-storey addition, despite hearing strong opposition from the...

  • City staff give thumbs up to Chateau Laurier redesign

    CBC NEWS, By Ryan Tumilty

    City staff are recommending council approve a proposed addition to the iconic Chateau Laurier that heritage advocates have denounced.

    In a report released...

Pages